# Cometly vs ClickMagick: quote or $79 cap · Postback Report

> Source: https://postbackreport.cc/compare/cometly-vs-clickmagick

## Cometly vs ClickMagick

You are down to two tools, and each one charges for a different thing.

Nadia Lindqvist, Affiliate tracking, updated 20 October 2026

**Disclosure:**We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our rankings. [How we research](/methodology). 

Pick Cometly if you run a B2B SaaS funnel on Stripe plus HubSpot or Salesforce and need closed-won or paying-customer events sent server-side to ad platforms from one quoted pageview plan; pick ClickMagick if you buy traffic to offers you control, want a published $79 entry plan with CAPI on Starter, and can live inside a 10,000-visitor cap with one ad account per platform.

Cometly matches the ad click to the person who later paid, or to the deal that closed, and sends that event to the ad platform. ClickMagick counts tracked visitors and the conversions you tag, on tiers you can read before anyone books a call.

[See ClickMagick pricing](/reviews/clickmagick/pricing)

### What gets sent back to Meta and Google

[Cometly's homepage](https://www.cometly.com/) presents the product as AI marketing attribution for B2B SaaS companies. It treats Stripe as the record of who paid and the ad platforms as the record of who clicked. Cometly is how those two records meet. The homepage ties trials, paid conversions, and renewals back to ad spend.

[The Conversion API page](https://www.cometly.com/platform/conversion-api) names paying customers, demos attended, and closed-won deals as events you can send. [Cometly pricing](https://www.cometly.com/pricing) puts unlimited connections to Meta, Google, LinkedIn, TikTok, Microsoft, Reddit, and Snapchat, including server-side Conversion API, on both Core and Enterprise. Core also lists server-side tracking, multi-touch attribution, and AI Ads Manager.

[ClickMagick's pricing page](https://www.clickmagick.com/pricing/) includes Audience Optimization / CAPI on the first paid tier. That tier also includes one user, one site, and one ad account per platform. The visitor allowance is the figure in the first paragraph. You can buy that plan without a meeting, and the server-side upload is already on it.

The two uploads aim at different records. Cometly's is a Stripe charge or a CRM stage. ClickMagick's is a conversion you marked in the tracker, including a network postback when the campaign is set up for one. A browser event and a server event can still both arrive for a single sale. Read [Facebook pixel vs Conversions API](/compare/facebook-pixel-vs-conversion-api) for how those two copies of one sale are kept apart. Read [which entry plan sends the sale to Meta and Google](/best/server-side-signal-checker-which-entry-plan-sends-the-sale-to-meta-and-google). That guide compares starter tiers by the conversion each one says it sends.

### When Cometly is the better fit

Cometly is for a SaaS team that runs its pipeline in HubSpot or Salesforce. A click count leaves out a renewal and a deal that took weeks to close. When the ad platform should learn from a paying customer, Cometly is the product that says it will send that event.

The bill is a quote sized to monthly pageviews. Each plan follows the pageviews the site already gets, and neither Core nor Enterprise shows a dollar amount. Cometly counts a pageview every time a page loads and the Comet Pixel, or a server-side event, records it. Budget for the sales conversation and for onboarding.

Cometly skips a self-serve trial because the CRM and the ad platforms have to be connected before the data is useful. New Core customers go through Professional Onboarding, listed as 60 days. That onboarding is not shown as its own charge. [Trustpilot reviews](https://www.trustpilot.com/review/cometly.com) describe the quoted price as high. The sales call is still required.

Once you are over the pageview tier, attribution keeps running. Cometly says it never throttles the data, notifies you at 90 percent of the tier, and moves you to the next tier at the start of the next billing period. Enterprise adds CRM and warehouse sync, MCP, API access, and Snowflake or BigQuery. Core already includes the Conversion API, so the warehouse sync is what the higher quote is for.

### When ClickMagick is the better fit

ClickMagick fits direct-response offers and affiliate campaigns if you need the allowance in writing before you pay. The pricing page opens with a 14-day free trial. Signup adds "Don't pay today" and does not say whether a card is collected. You can see the tiers before a call.

The entry tier carries CAPI, the visitor allowance, and a single ad account on each platform. A second Meta account, or a second site, sits outside that list even when the visitor count would still fit. Unlimited affiliate campaigns are included on Standard at $199 a month, and that tier's allowance is 100,000 tracked visitors. Pro is $349 a month, for 1,000,000 tracked visitors. ClickMagick has been selling this tracker since 2014, and the tiers are on a public page.

No per-visitor rate is printed once that count is used up, and nothing there says the tracker shuts off. The next published step is the next tier. If you have already outgrown that allowance, read [ClickMagick vs Voluum](/compare/clickmagick-vs-voluum) for the event-pool comparison. For a larger pool and the upload on the first affiliate plan, read [RedTrack vs ClickMagick](/compare/redtrack-vs-clickmagick). When the sale closes on a call and the price follows tracked revenue, read [ClickMagick vs Hyros](/compare/clickmagick-vs-hyros).

### ClickMagick vs Cometly on the meter

ClickMagick vs Cometly is a unit problem before it is a feature problem. ClickMagick meters tracked visitors. Cometly meters pageviews and estimates about 1.5 pageviews per session. A forecast that starts from sessions lands lower than a pageview quote for that reason.

The yearly deals diverge the same way. Cometly says paying annually saves 20 percent. The yearly plan still shows no dollar amount. ClickMagick's terms include two months free on an annual plan, and the entry year is $790, printed as $66 a month. The trial and the refund terms are written up on [ClickMagick pricing, trial, and annual billing](/reviews/clickmagick/pricing).

### A Cometly alternative with a printed price

People looking for a Cometly alternative have usually stalled on the custom quote or on the lack of a trial. ClickMagick is the match if you can tag the conversion, stay inside the starter allowance, and work from a single ad login.

RedTrack is the step up when the event pool is the constraint and you still want the upload on the first paid affiliate plan. ElasticFunnels fits if the page, the same-URL test, the checkout, and the ad report should live in one product. If the landing pages already live somewhere else, you still want a tracker. The funnel-platform case is the next section.

Quick answer

**Cometly** is our top pick for most people. Cometly fits when Stripe or the CRM should send paying customers and closed-won deals back to the ad platforms. 

* **Cometly.** Best for B2B SaaS teams sending Stripe or CRM revenue back to ads.
* **ClickMagick.** Best for an account with a visitor cap. From $79/mo.

### The entry plans side by side

The price column shows the starting monthly price. A blank cell means that product's feature list does not mention it.

__Feature comparison across 2 tools__
| Tool           | Meter           | Listed price | Trial         | Entry CAPI | Revenue source              | Affiliate             | From       |
| -------------- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --------------------- | ---------- |
| Cometly        | Pageviews       | Quote only   | No free trial | On Core    | Stripe, HubSpot, Salesforce | –Unknown              | Not listed |
| 3. ClickMagick | 10,000 visitors | $79/mo       | 14 days       | On Starter | Clicks and postbacks        | Unlimited on Standard | $79/mo     |

### Cometly

##### What works

* Core includes server-side Conversion API for the major ad platforms.
* Supported events include paying customers, attended demos, and closed-won deals.
* Tracking continues after the pageview limit, and the next tier starts on the following bill.

##### What to watch

* The starting price is a sales quote. No dollar figure is published.
* Professional Onboarding replaces a trial for a new Core account.
* Reviewers on Trustpilot call that quote high.

### ClickMagick

##### What works

* Starter includes Audience Optimization, which the pricing page lists as CAPI.
* The entry plan is the lowest of the three we priced, and the trial is 14 days.
* A first-party tracking domain is on the Starter feature list.

##### What to watch

* Starter includes 10,000 tracked visitors and one ad account per platform.
* Affiliate campaigns without a cap are listed on Standard. Starter keeps data for six months.
* The pricing page does not state what happens once you exceed the visitor allowance.

### A pageview quote against a visitor cap

Cometly offers Core and Enterprise. Both are priced from monthly pageviews on a sales call. Annual billing is the lower quote already described in the meter section. Neither column shows a dollar amount.

The table's ClickMagick row is the entry tier. Standard and Pro, at the prices above, are the two steps after it. After the Starter allowance, no extra-visitor charge is shown. The [ClickMagick review](/reviews/clickmagick) covers that entry plan in full.

### When the page, the test, and the checkout live in one product

Cometly and ClickMagick record a click and a later outcome. The landing page and the checkout still live in other products. ElasticFunnels is a funnel platform for teams that run paid traffic. The page, the same-URL test, the checkout, and the ad report live in one product. A click, an order, a rebill, and a refund stay together.

Variants rotate on the server under one campaign link. Meta, Google, and TikTok keep the learning they already have on that link. The test keeps the URL already on the ad, so the platforms do not open a new review. The platform also builds pages from a prompt or by cloning a URL. Checkout can take order bumps, one-click upsells, and subscriptions. The platform also includes attribution, a CRM, automations, and a call center.

Every feature is on every plan. Plans differ by page views, brands, domains, team seats, and automation runs. Starter is $97 a month, with 50,000 page views, or $937 billed for the year. The trial lasts 14 days and does not ask for a credit card. Pages, funnels, and a custom domain can be set up while it runs. A 0.5 percent fee applies to revenue processed through Stripe, NMI, PayPal, Klarna, or Authorize.net. Sales through an external checkout or a network are exempt from that fee.

ElasticFunnels is newer than the platforms it competes with, and there is very little independent third-party review coverage to check its claims against. Until you run real volume through it, you are largely taking the vendor's word for how attribution behaves. It has been on the market since 2023, so few independent reviews of the tracking have had time to appear. Before you buy, few outside reviews cover the attribution. Pages, checkout, and the CRM still come with every plan.

Buyers who weigh funnel platforms look at ClickFunnels for pages and at Konnektive for checkout. A team whose landers and checkout already exist elsewhere still buys a tracker for the click and the postback. Read [ElasticFunnels vs ClickFunnels](/compare/elasticfunnels-vs-clickfunnels) if you are choosing a page builder. Limits and the rest of the plan cards are in [the ElasticFunnels review](/reviews/elasticfunnels).

### Where I would start

I would take Cometly's quote when the target is a paying customer or a closed deal in Stripe or the CRM, and someone on the team can sit through onboarding. For an offer I control, inside the entry allowance, with one login on the ad side, I open ClickMagick and read the tiers first.

Every other pair is listed on [the head-to-head index](/compare).

Our pick

### Cometly

Cometly fits when Stripe or the CRM should send paying customers and closed-won deals back to the ad platforms.

### Questions

Is the server-side upload on the first paid plan? 

Cometly includes server-side Conversion API on Core, the quoted starting plan. ClickMagick lists Audience Optimization, the CAPI line, on its first paid tier.

Can I try Cometly before paying? 

Cometly does not run one. Core accounts go through Professional Onboarding, because the CRM and the ad accounts have to be connected before the numbers mean anything.

What happens after the ClickMagick visitor allowance? 

The public plan list does not price an extra visitor, and it does not say tracking stops. The next allowance it does print is the following tier.

Where do I look if I want a price without a Cometly sales call? 

ClickMagick, when a printed visitor plan and a short trial match the offer you control. RedTrack, when you need a larger event pool. ElasticFunnels, when the page and the checkout should share the record with the ad report.

### What we read

#### From Cometly

* <https://www.cometly.com/>

### ClickMagick pages

#### From ClickMagick

* <https://www.clickmagick.com/>

### Where to read the next pair

* [ClickMagick pricing, trial, and annual billing](/reviews/clickmagick/pricing), including the yearly total.
* [ClickMagick review](/reviews/clickmagick), the entry plan on its own page.
* [Cometly review](/reviews/cometly), the quote-only plan on its own page.
* [Cometly pricing](/reviews/cometly/pricing), the pageview quote and the missing trial.
* [RedTrack vs ClickMagick](/compare/redtrack-vs-clickmagick), for a larger event pool and CAPI on Solo.
* [ClickMagick vs Voluum](/compare/clickmagick-vs-voluum), when campaigns outgrow the visitor cap.
* [ClickMagick vs Hyros](/compare/clickmagick-vs-hyros), when sales close on calls.
* [Facebook pixel vs Conversions API](/compare/facebook-pixel-vs-conversion-api), which path sends the Meta event.
* [Which entry plan sends the sale to Meta and Google](/best/server-side-signal-checker-which-entry-plan-sends-the-sale-to-meta-and-google).
* [ElasticFunnels review](/reviews/elasticfunnels), covering pages, checkout, and ad reporting together.
* [All head-to-heads](/compare).

[See ClickMagick pricing](/reviews/clickmagick/pricing)

Written by

Nadia Lindqvist

Affiliate tracking

Nadia covers affiliate tracking software for people who buy Meta and Google traffic. She reads vendor pricing pages, documentation and long-term user reports, and she writes about which tracker fits a given buyer.

[nadial@postbackreport.cc](mailto:nadial@postbackreport.cc)

Last checked 2026-10-20

---

[ Postback Report ](/) 

Postback Report ranks affiliate tracking software for media buyers running Meta and Google direct response, judged on postbacks, cost, and the Conversions API.

[Contact](/contact)

Postback Report

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our rankings.

© 2026 Postback Report. Independent and reader-supported.